Home › Best cigars
Best cigars of 2026
The premium cigars most reviewed by independent cigar review sites, grouped by what you're looking for. We rank by how many independent reviewers have covered each cigar, never by payment.
Best cigars for beginners
Mild and mild-medium cigars that independent reviewers cover most.
Connecticut
Mild–MediumEcuadorian Connecticut wrapper · Honduras
reviewed by 9 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Romeo y JulietaReserva Real
Mild–MediumEcuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper · Dominican Republic
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Drew EstateUndercrown Shade
Mild–MediumEcuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 7 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hoyo de MonterreyExcalibur
Mild–MediumConnecticut Shade wrapper · Honduras
reviewed by 7 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Romeo y Julieta1875
Mild–MediumIndonesian wrapper · Dominican Republic
reviewed by 7 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
FoundationCharter Oak
Mild–MediumConnecticut Shade or Broadleaf Maduro wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 6 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gemBest medium cigars
Balanced, medium-strength cigars with the widest review coverage.
Joya Red
MediumNicaraguan wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 11 sites · 10 r/cigars threads
Hidden gemArturo FuenteDon Carlos
MediumCameroon wrapper · Dominican Republic
reviewed by 9 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
PlasenciaAlma del Campo
MediumNicaraguan wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 9 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
TatuajeHavana VI
MediumEcuadorian Habano wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 9 sites · 27 r/cigars threads
Hidden gemWarpedFuturo
MediumNicaraguan Corojo '99 wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 9 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gemAladinoCameroon
MediumCameroon wrapper · Honduras
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Best full-bodied cigars
Medium-full and full cigars for experienced smokers.
Corojo
Medium–FullHonduran Corojo wrapper · Honduras
reviewed by 9 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
AJ FernandezBellas Artes
Medium–FullNicaraguan Rojita (proprietary hybrid) wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
AJ FernandezNew World Dorado
Medium–FullNicaraguan Habano sun grown wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 8 sites · critics 93 · 30+ r/cigars threads
Aging RoomQuattro Nicaragua
Medium–FullNicaraguan wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 8 sites · critics 95 · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gemAlec BradleyMagic Toast
Medium–FullHonduran wrapper · Honduras
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
CaldwellLong Live the King
Medium–FullDominican Corojo wrapper · Dominican Republic
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gemBest maduro cigars
Dark, sweet maduro and broadleaf-wrapped cigars.
Herrera Estelí Norteño
Medium–FullMexican San Andrés wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Drew EstateLiga Privada No. 9
Medium–FullConnecticut Broadleaf wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Drew EstateUndercrown 10
Medium–FullMexican San Andrés wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Dunbarton Tobacco & TrustMi Querida
Medium–FullConnecticut Broadleaf wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gemFoundationThe Tabernacle
Medium–FullConnecticut Broadleaf wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gemIllusioneRothchildes
MediumMexican San Andrés wrapper · Honduras
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gemBest Connecticut cigars
Smooth, creamy shade-wrapped cigars.
Connecticut
Mild–MediumEcuadorian Connecticut wrapper · Honduras
reviewed by 9 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Romeo y JulietaReserva Real
Mild–MediumEcuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper · Dominican Republic
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
CaldwellEastern Standard
MediumConnecticut Shade wrapper · Dominican Republic
reviewed by 7 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gemDrew EstateBlackened S84
MediumEcuadorian Connecticut wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 7 sites · 23 r/cigars threads
Hidden gemDrew EstateUndercrown Shade
Mild–MediumEcuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 7 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hoyo de MonterreyExcalibur
Mild–MediumConnecticut Shade wrapper · Honduras
reviewed by 7 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gems
Well reviewed but boutique or less talked about.
Joya Red
MediumNicaraguan wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 11 sites · 10 r/cigars threads
Hidden gemTatuajeHavana VI
MediumEcuadorian Habano wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 9 sites · 27 r/cigars threads
Hidden gemWarpedFuturo
MediumNicaraguan Corojo '99 wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 9 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gemAging RoomQuattro Nicaragua
Medium–FullNicaraguan wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 8 sites · critics 95 · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gemCaldwellLong Live the King
Medium–FullDominican Corojo wrapper · Dominican Republic
reviewed by 8 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
Hidden gemDavidoffNicaragua
Medium–FullNicaraguan Habano Rosado wrapper
reviewed by 8 sites · 27 r/cigars threads
Hidden gemHow we rank: for each cigar we count which of 27 independent review sites have reviewed it (November 2026). It measures attention from reviewers, not a taste test. See the full data.
