My Father The Judge
Big, box-pressed sizes.
Blend and specs
| Brand | My Father |
|---|---|
| Made in | Nicaragua |
| Maker | My Father Cigars (Garcia family) |
| Wrapper | Ecuadorian Sumatra |
| Binder | Nicaragua |
| Filler | Nicaragua |
| Strength | Medium–Full |
| Wrapper family | Sumatra (sweet spice) |
| Shape | Box-pressed |
| Brand type | Independent / family |
Specs come from published maker and retailer information. Tobacco origins can change between production runs; check the box or band for the cigar you're buying.
What reviewers and smokers say
Reviewed on: cigar-coop.com, cigaraficionado.com, cigardojo.com, halfwheel.com, kohnhed.com, leafenthusiast.com. Counts come from Google results collected in November 2026; scores are those quoted in review snippets. See what the data shows.
Rate the The Judge
Be the first Cigar.co smoker to rate it.
What did you taste? (optional, pick up to 6)
One rating per smoker per cigar; you can change it any time. For adults 21+.
If you like the The Judge, try
Serie V Melanio
Medium–FullEcuadorian Sumatra wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 7 sites · critics 91 · 30+ r/cigars threads
98% matchsame strength · same wrapper style · Ecuador wrapper · rolled in Nicaragua · Nicaragua filler
OzgenerBosphorus
Medium–FullEcuadorian Sumatra wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 4 sites · critics 91 · 30+ r/cigars threads
96% matchsame strength · same wrapper style · Ecuador wrapper · rolled in Nicaragua · Nicaragua filler
San CristobalRevelation
MediumEcuadorian Sumatra wrapper · Nicaragua
78% matchsame wrapper style · Ecuador wrapper · rolled in Nicaragua · Nicaragua filler · shared notes: cedar
AJ FernandezEnclave
Medium–FullEcuadorian Habano wrapper · Nicaragua
reviewed by 7 sites · 30+ r/cigars threads
76% matchsame strength · Ecuador wrapper · rolled in Nicaragua · Nicaragua filler · shared notes: cedar, cocoa
A lesser-known pick
See all matches for the The Judge →
Common questions
What wrapper does the My Father The Judge use?
The My Father The Judge uses a Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper, with a Nicaragua binder and Nicaragua filler.
How strong is the My Father The Judge?
It's generally rated medium to full in strength (4 on our 5-point scale).
Where is the My Father The Judge made?
In Nicaragua.
If I like the My Father The Judge, what else should I try?
Our closest matches are Oliva Serie V Melanio (98%), Ozgener Bosphorus (96%), San Cristobal Revelation (78%), AJ Fernandez Enclave (76%). For something less well known, try the Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Sobremesa.
